Reddit Debate: Does ‘Rocky Aur Rani Kii Prem Kahaani' Justify Adultery?
Karan Johar's latest romantic comedy, “Rocky Aur Rani Kii Prem Kahaani,“ has triggered a lively debate on Reddit concerning its treatment of adultery. The film showcases Dharmendra's character, Kawal, rekindling a past romance with Shabana Azmi's character, Jamini, despite being married to Jaya Bachchan's character. This plot point has sparked discussions on whether the film justifies or glorifies adultery.
The debate began when a Reddit user posted a tweet featuring a still from the movie and criticized Karan Johar's alleged obsession with infidelity. The tweet suggested that the movie not only glorified but also justified cheating, asserting that infidelity is never acceptable, regardless of relationship struggles.
In response, another Reddit user captured the tweet and initiated a thread titled “Can we stop normalizing adultery!” However, the argument faced opposition from several users. One user pointed out that while cheating is problematic, the film also highlights the importance of addressing abusive relationships and the various factors that keep individuals tied to such marriages.
Another commenter acknowledged that Karan Johar and even Zoya Akhtar, to some extent, have portrayed infidelity in their films. However, they argued that the depiction in “Rocky Aur Rani” was particularly compelling and empathetic.
They emphasized that while cheating should never be endorsed, the film presented a complex portrayal of the characters' struggles, especially considering the abusive nature of Shabana Azmi's character's previous marriage.
The debate extended to Zoya Akhtar's filmography, with one user questioning whether her films truly justify cheating. Examples were given, such as Anil Kapoor's character in “Dil Dhadakne Do,” who is portrayed negatively due to his infidelity, and Farhan Akhtar's character in “Zindagi Na Milegi Dobara,” where his unfaithfulness serves as a pivotal point for character growth.
The discussion also delved into the abusive environments depicted in the film. One user pointed out that both main characters were trapped in unhappy marriages due to their spouses' actions. The film illustrates the impact of an abusive household on relationships, as seen in the characters' troubled family dynamics.
Critics of the film's portrayal of adultery raised concerns about toxic marriages being normalized. They argued that while leaving such relationships is difficult, normalizing toxicity could lead to prolonged suffering for individuals.
Counterarguments were presented as well. One user stressed that watching a film doesn't necessarily inspire viewers to commit adultery, just as watching heist movies doesn't incite real-life theft. They argued that art imitates life, and while Karan Johar's frequent use of adultery as a plot device can be tiresome, it doesn't equate to endorsing the behavior.
Another user emphasized the need to refrain from moral policing and allow consenting adults to make their own choices. They highlighted that adultery isn't illegal after 2017 and argued that moral policing poses a greater threat to society than adultery itself.
In conclusion, the Reddit debate surrounding “Rocky Aur Rani Kii Prem Kahaani” raises thought-provoking questions about the portrayal of adultery in cinema, the complexities of relationships, and the broader impact of media on societal attitudes. The discussion underscores the importance of critical analysis while acknowledging the nuances of artistic expression and its influence on real-life behaviors.
Click for more updates and the latest Bollywood news along with Entertainment updates. Also, get the latest news and top headlines from India and around the world at Speed News.
